I work as a freelance 1st AD and as an editor, so I see directing from both ends: the day on set and the footage that comes out of it. This is the core of what makes a shooting day work. Prep - Answer Lumet's question first: what is this movie about? He keeps returning to it in 'Making Movies', and every later choice, from lenses to costume, gets checked against the answer. - Break the script down scene by scene: cast, locations, props, effects, day or night. Scene length is counted in eighths of a page, and a page plays as roughly a minute. - Shot list for every scene; storyboards for action, VFX and any precise camera move. The shot list is what the AD schedules from. On the day - Block, light, rehearse, shoot. Show the blocking to the DP and department heads before lighting starts. A quiet rehearsal with the actors first protects their process and gives the crew real marks. - Shoot the widest shot first so continuity and geography are set, then move in. Group setups facing one direction, then do the turnaround, so you light each side once. - Keep the 180-degree rule: the camera stays on one side of the line between two characters, so eyelines and screen direction stay consistent. Cross it on purpose, with a move the audience sees or a neutral shot, and tell the script supervisor. Actors - Give playable actions: a verb the actor can do to the other character. Judith Weston's 'Directing Actors' is the standard text. A result note like 'be angrier' leaves the actor guessing. - Give notes quietly, close, one at a time. Department heads - Tell them why. A designer who knows the room has to feel like a trap will solve problems you never thought of. - '12 Angry Men' is the classic case: Lumet planned a lens plot so the jury room seems to shrink as the film goes on. Sources: - Sidney Lumet, Making Movies, reviewed in DGA Quarterly, https://www.dga.org/craft/dgaq/issues/1101-spring-2011/books-sidney-lumet - Judith Weston, Directing Actors, https://judithweston.com - BFI, How 12 Angry Men works, https://www.bfi.org.uk/features/how-12-angry-men-works-25-frames
Director here, one addition on shot lists: number every setup and mark the must-haves. When the day runs late, the AD and I cut from the bottom of the list without a debate. On my first feature I storyboarded everything and used maybe a third of the boards. On the second I boarded only the sci-fi sequences, and the days went faster.
From the actor side of playable actions: the most useful note I ever got was 'make him stay'. The least useful was 'can you do it sadder'. The first gives me something to do to my partner; the second makes me watch myself. Also, tell us which shot is next and how tight it is. We pace a wide and a close-up differently.
DP's plea: show me the blocking before anyone says 'light it'. Ten minutes of watching a rehearsal saves an hour of relighting when the actor ends up a metre from where the stand-in was. And let me see it from the camera side, with the actors at performance pace.