Producer question. Our DP wants to shoot the beach scenes close to wide open, around T2, at EI 800 and 24 fps. I need to sign off the filter list for the rental today and I don't know whether we need two NDs or eight. What should a realistic list look like?
Rough math with the sunny 16 rule: in direct sun, f/16 at a shutter of 1/ISO, so f/16 at 1/800 for EI 800. A 180 degree shutter at 24 fps is 1/48, about four stops more light, so the scene wants roughly f/64. From f/64 down to T2 is ten stops. That is about ND 3.0 total. If the camera has internal ND, use it, then stack the rest in the matte box. On a Mini LF the internal ND covers 0.6, 1.2 and 1.8, so add 0.6 and 1.2 externally and you have range. Rent full spectrum or IRND, because at these densities plain ND lets infrared in and dark clothes go muddy. Source: ARRI, FSND filters, https://arri.com/en/cine-lenses/lens-accessories/fsnd-filter
From the schedule side: internal ND is a menu change, a matte box filter is a reach-in, a screw-on filter stack is a lens change. When the sun goes in and out of clouds on a beach, that difference is minutes per setup, and on a beach day those minutes are your light. Keep the heaviest filter in the matte box and ride the internal ND for the clouds.
We rented two IRNDs for the matte box, a 0.6 and a 1.2, and leaned on the internal ND for everything else. Never ran out, even at noon, and the DP stopped asking me for more glass. Saved a bit on the filter list too, because the first quote had a full set of plain ND that we would have stacked three deep. Keeping this thread for the next budget.